There are few things better in combat sports than a heated rivalry, and a feud’s heat turns up a few notches when there is a title involved.
There is no love lost between reigning bantamweight champion TJ Dillashaw and the man he toppled 14 months ago to take the championship—Renan Barao. While the Brazilian phenom was slated to get an immediate rematch after being dethroned by the Team Alpha Male standout at UFC 173, weight-cutting debacles and injuries have stretched out their rematch for more than a year.
The 29-year-old Sacramento-based titleholder would make his successful defense of the bantamweight strap in the interim, while Barao waited patiently for his chance at redemption. Their paths finally crossed once again at UFC on Fox 16 in Chicago.
Barao came into the main event tilt looking to prove his loss to Dillashaw was a fluke and reclaim the 135-pound title, while The Ultimate Fighter alum was determined to cement his place as the king of the bantamweight collective.
The stakes were high on Saturday night in the Windy City, and it was Dillashaw who stamped his place as the king of the bantamweight division. In what was another brilliant performance from Duane Ludwig’s protege, Dillashaw used his striking to take the fight out of the former champion throughout the fight’s first three rounds. Shortly after the fourth frame began, a flurry from Dillashaw against the cage forced referee Herb Dean to step in and bring a stop to the action.
With the win, Dillashaw not only puts the cap on his rivalry with Barao, but he also further validates his claim as the man to beat in the 135-pound division.
Let’s take a look at the good, bad and strange from UFC on Fox 16.
The Good
It’s safe to say Dillashaw is a bad man. And the scary part is, he’s only getting better.
The reigning bantamweight champion put his longstanding rivalry with Renan Barao to rest as he stopped the Nova Uniao representative in the fourth round of their UFC on Fox 16 tilt. Once again it was Dillashaw’s striking that made the difference as the Team Alpha Male fighter battered Barao in heavy exchanges throughout the fight, until multiple shots in a rapid-fire flurry put the Brazilian away in the fourth round.
In the post-fight interview, Joe Rogan remarked that Dillashaw continues to improve at an incredible rate, and his transformation from a wrestler with a bit of power in his punches, to an elusive striker with dangerous accuracy has been something special to witness. Throughout his run to the title and back-to-back successful defenses, Dillashaw has shown he’s head and shoulders above the rest of the bantamweight division.
The only potential threat lingering in the distance is a possible showdown with former champion Dominick Cruz in a fight that would serve to erase any shred of doubt as to who the true king of the 135-pound fold is.
*** Miesha Tate has been doing everything in her power to earn another shot at Ronda Rousey, and Cupcake may have officially sealed the deal at UFC on Fox 16.
The former Strikeforce women’s bantamweight champion and UFC title contender put on a dominant performance as she battered Jessica Eye in the co-main event of Saturday’s card in Chicago. Though Tate has relied on her wrestling prowess to defeat the majority of her past opponents, it was the Washington state native’s ever-improving striking game that made the difference against Eye.
The cageside judges’ unanimous decision gave Tate her fourth consecutive victory in the women’s 135-pound division. It will be interesting to see how things play out going forward. Rousey has twice defeated her, with both losses coming in definitive fashion.
Anytime a fighter has been toppled by the standing champion, getting a third shot is going to be difficult to come by. Yet, Tate has refused to be detoured from getting another championship opportunity, and a title shot could very well be in her immediate future.
*** Many expected the fight between Edson Barboza and Paul Felder was going to be an action-packed shootout, and it absolutely delivered. The Brazilian striking machine and the Donald Cerrone protege spent the entire three rounds of the fight punishing one another with a wide array of kicks, knees and punches.
By the start of the third and final round, the United Center crowd was standing on its feet in an uproar for more, and the two lightweights spent the final five minutes giving them more of the same. While Barboza would go on to take the unanimous-decision victory, the Irish Dragon has nothing to hang his head about as he proved he can go toe-to-toe with the divisional elite at 155.
*** Moving up a weight class proved to be a great decision for Tom Lawlor as the “Filthy” one iced Gian Villante in the second round of their clash.
After spending the past six years competing in the 185-pound division, Lawlor made his return to light heavyweight to face the Serra-Longo fighter. And while many thought the 32-year-old pro wrestling enthusiast would use his grappling chops to pursue victory, it was a rock-solid right hand that put Villante down for the count.
In his post-fight interview, Lawlor said he’s going to stay at 205, and there will be plenty of interesting matchups for him down the road in that division.
*** There are few fighters in the lightweight upper-tier ranks who can say they’ve been fighting as long as Jim Miller has. The New Jersey native made his 20th appearance inside the Octagon against Danny Castillo at UFC on Fox 16 and turned it into a successful one, employing his signature brand of toughness inside the cage.
While both fighters had their moments throughout the bout, it was Miller who used his wrestling and counterstriking to tip the balance with the judges sitting cageside as he picked up the split-decision win to pull himself out of his recent two-fight slump.
*** Ben Saunders is making the most of his return to the UFC. Killa B came into his fight with Kenny Robertson having won both of his fights since coming back to the Octagon in 2014, and he made it three straight wins by besting the Illinois native in a gritty three-round war.
While Robertson jumped out to an early lead with a strong first round, the American Top Team product relied on his experience and ever-improving ground game to steal the momentum and, ultimately, the fight, in the final frame.
The Florida-based welterweight turned Robertson into a blood-soaked mess as he bombed away on him with elbows while attempting to lock on a triangle choke from his back. The end result was a split-decision victory for Saunders. His march up the 170-pound ranks will pick up steam after Saturday night. Ted Gruber was very descriptive in describing Robertson’s shorts:
*** Bryan Caraway’s ultimate goal is climbing the ladder toward a shot at the bantamweight title, and he took a step in that direction on Saturday night in Chicago. The Washington state native went toe-to-toe with scrappy veteran Eddie Wineland and got the better of the scrappy veteran in the majority of exchanges en route to picking up his fourth victory in his past five outings.
By defeating the Indiana native, Caraway not only put himself back into the win column, but he also notched a win over one of the most established names in the 135-pound fold. More importantly, he didn’t decide to coast in a close fight’s final frame. USA Today columnist Ben Fowlkes was impressed with Caraway’s performance:
*** James Krause came into UFC on Fox 16 in desperate need of a victory to retain his spot on the crowded lightweight roster, and he wasted little time getting the job done against Daron Cruickshank.
The Kansas City native took the fight directly to his opponent from the opening bell, but he turned up his intensity once the action hit the ground. Moments later Krause secured the fight-ending rear-naked choke to take the win and snap a two-fight losing skid inside the Octagon.
It was an impressive showing for Krause in Chicago and one that will retain his place on the 155-pound roster intact. USA Today reporter Chamatkar Sandhu described Krause’s in-ring action as “freakin awesome”:
*** It wasn’t the performance Andrew Holbrook wanted to put on for his official UFC debut against Ramsey Nijem, but he’ll take the results as he picked up a split-decision victory on Saturday. In what played out as a technical—and at moments strange—battle on the canvas, the Indiana native consistently looked for every submission attempt he could find throughout the three-round affair.
And while the crowd at the United Center heavily disagreed with Holbrook taking the bout on the judges’ scorecards, leaving Chicago with a victory over a named opponent like Nijem in his first showing is a solid start to his UFC career. MMAFighting.com’s Dave Doyle cleverly referenced “hometown cooking”:
The Bad
There was a time when Takanori Gomi was the most feared lightweight fighter on the planet. Those days have officially come and gone.
While The Fireball Kid once ruled the Pride organization’s 155-pound ranks with an iron fist that he used to level opponent after opponent with, the past five years have shown there is very little left in him that resembles the knockout artist he once was.
Gomi made his highly anticipated UFC debut back in 2010, and the time since has produced mixed results that weigh heavy on the disappointing side. Granted, there have been flashes of the power he built his career upon, but in the long run, those flashes haven’t panned out.
The 36-year-old Tokyo-based fighter came into his bout with Joe Lauzon at UFC on Fox 16 having won only four of his 10 showings inside the Octagon, and he desperately needed a victory to show he could still compete with what the lightweight division’s best had to offer. Instead, Lauzon put Gomi down and out in quick fashion in the first round of their tilt, in what was one of the weirdest finishes in recent memory.
Yet, even with pushing referee Herb Dean’s nonchalance toward the action aside, the moments leading up to Lauzon walking away saw a Gomi who was shy in letting his hands go. Although that could have been caused by the Massachusetts native’s style, it was still a strange look for a fighter who is notorious for letting his fists fly with reckless abandon.
With the loss, Gomi has now been turned back in consecutive outings and has been bested in three of his last four fights. Those numbers don’t necessarily spell the beginning of the end for fighters in most cases, but with his age and fall from grace, one has to wonder just how long he will try to keep his fighting career alive.
*** Things won’t be looking too good for Jessamyn Duke following her loss to Elizabeth Phillips. The once-touted bantamweight and member of Ronda Rousey’s Four Horsewomen suffered her third consecutive setback inside the Octagon as she came out on the business end of a unanimous decision on the judges’ scorecards.
While Duke poured on the action in the third and final frame, it was too little too late to turn the fight’s tide. With the loss, Duke as of now been defeated in all but one of her four showings under the UFC banner. She could very well be heading back to Invicta for the foreseeable future. Bleacher Report’s Jeremy Botter summed up Duke’s dismal performance in one word—”bad”:
The Strange
Whether it’s a stock line in an interview or just a generalized fighter mantra in MMA, allowing fights to go to the judges’ cards is a roll of the dice.
It seems like every card the UFC puts on, the judging collective makes at least one questionable call. UFC on Fox 16 kept that streak going strong. It was a night of split decisions in Chicago, and more than a few of them were of the head-scratching variety. Three of the first seven fights played out in that fashion, and two of them truly could have gone either way.
The only one that seemed to draw the MMA community total ire was the preliminary-card bout between Ramsey Nijem and UFC newcomer Andrew Holbrook. While the majority of the bout saw the two lightweights locked in various forms of stalemates on the canvas, the general consensus on social media—and definitely inside the United Center—was that Nijem should have had his hand raised at fight’s end.
Yet, that’s not how it would shake out as two of the three judges sitting cageside saw the fight going in the Indiana native’s favor. It wasn’t the most popular decision, but it was the final one.
Now, as strange as some of those calls were, nothing was quite as bizarre as how the fight between Joe Lauzon and Takanori Gomi ended. The Fireball Kid and the TUF alum stepped in to handle some business in the lightweight division, and a few minutes later it was all over. At least Lauzon knew it was all over, and he seemed to be the only man in the cage that did.
After pummeling the Japanese veteran with heavy shots on the ground, J-Lau suddenly stopped his onslaught, stood up and raised his hands in victory, while referee Herb Dean looked on as a dazed Gomi crawled about.
Lauzon got a few steps away from his opponent and then realized the fight had yet to be officially called. He then turned his attention back to the matter at hand. Yet, before he could jump back in and throw more punches at a wounded Gomi, Dean waived his hands, and the fight was brought to an end. Sports journalist Adam Martin described referee’s performance as “some of the worst reffing seen in the UFC”:
There are many times fights end in fast-and-furious fashion, and the cause of the stoppage can be caught on the post-fight replay, but even that footage didn’t reveal any clear signs of why Lauzon let up. In his interview with Joe Rogan, the Massachusetts native said he saw his opponent go out and stop fighting, and having mercy on one of his personal heroes was the cause for the self-imposed stoppage.
A fighter taking his foot off the gas because he couldn’t bring himself to continue a beating? How’s that for strange?
Duane Finley is a featured columnist for Bleacher Report. All quotes are obtained firsthand unless noted otherwise.
Read more MMA news on BleacherReport.com