Power Ranking the 50 Best Fighters in MMA and UFC History

Legacy is important to all athletes, especially in the combat sports. Ask any two boxing fans who the best fighter of all time was, and more likely than not, an argument is about to begin.The same applies to MMA, despite a short history of just 19 year…

Legacy is important to all athletes, especially in the combat sports. Ask any two boxing fans who the best fighter of all time was, and more likely than not, an argument is about to begin.

The same applies to MMA, despite a short history of just 19 years. Using the power of math, we’ve broken down the best fighter debate into six categories. In addition to these statistical rankings, we’ve asked resident MMA historian Jonathan Snowden to create a panel and a set of rankings of his own.

Combining the objective and the subjective, we’ve narrowed down 50 of the best. Bleacher Report presents the 50 greatest fighters of all time.

Begin Slideshow

Daniel Cormier vs. Shane Carwin? Yeah, I Could Watch That

We know Daniel Cormier, unfortunately, has to stick around the now two-man Strikeforce heavyweight division for at least one more fight. In an ideal world, Cormier would be on his way to the UFC after his re-broken hand heals up.So yeah, it’s unfortuna…

We know Daniel Cormier, unfortunately, has to stick around the now two-man Strikeforce heavyweight division for at least one more fight. In an ideal world, Cormier would be on his way to the UFC after his re-broken hand heals up.

So yeah, it’s unfortunate that we won’t be seeing Cormier make his UFC debut in his next fight. But it’s not the end of the world. There are zero heavyweights left in Strikeforce besides Cormier and Josh Barnett, and we don’t really need to see that fight again. The idea of bringing in an outside name like Tim Sylvia has a little appeal, but only because seeing the out-of-shape Sylvia being battered around the cage by Cormier would be intriguing. 

Cormier sticking around Strikeforce for one more fight isn’t all that bad because there are plenty of UFC heavyweights who could move over for one big fight against the grand prix winner. As I’ve said before, I wouldn’t mind seeing him fight someone like Travis Browne, but Cormier has a much better idea, as he told Ariel Helwani on yesterday’s edition of The MMA Hour:

I think if there is a plus one and Zuffa’s going to send someone over it is going to have to be someone that is very good you know? Maybe Shane Carwin, as he’s coming back. He’s a guy with a lot of name value and I don’t necessarily know if that’s a step up (from Josh Barnett) but that is somebody with name value.

Oh my. That’s quite the idea right there. Carwin’s been gone from the cage for nearly a year at this point, and we don’t know exactly what kind of condition he’ll be in when he gets back. But this is an intriguing idea, with the perfect mix of challenge and name value for Cormier’s next opponent. 

I like it. No, I love it. Book it, Joe.

Read more MMA news on BleacherReport.com

Nevada Plays Favorites with Steroid Users but Hates Marijuana

The UFC’s issues with drug-related failures are a problem, but they have yet to reach epidemic levels. Not yet, anyway.Truthfully, they haven’t even come close to damaging as many fights as training injuries have. But the major drug-related cases we’ve…

The UFC’s issues with drug-related failures are a problem, but they have yet to reach epidemic levels. Not yet, anyway.

Truthfully, they haven’t even come close to damaging as many fights as training injuries have. But the major drug-related cases we’ve seen this year have been high-profile—witness the cases of Alistair Overeem and Nick Diaz—and thus the spotlight seems a little bit brighter than normal.

I’ve talked about the issue of performance-enhancing drugs here in the past, and I’ll continue to do so in the future. It’s an issue that isn’t going away anytime soon, and it looks like Dana White is finally amenable to taking drastic steps inside his own company to help clean up the sport before it gets out of control:

Lance Pugmire: (Junior dos Santos vs. Frank Mir) came together only because Alistair Overeem tested positive for testosterone. How devastating was that to your sport?

Dana White: “The steroid, PED thing affects the whole sport. The key is to make sure these guys never get on it, because once they do, they change. The problem with Overeem is that I want to sit in a room with him man to man and believe him. He told me before he ever fought for us, ‘Don’t worry, I’m the most tested athlete in sports.’ But I think we have about 42 fights a year . . . you have a guy or two popping [positive tests] here and there, that’s a pretty good ratio.”

LP: Do you want to increase testing?

DFW: “Yes. We’re going to do our own testing, order these guys into [a lab]; we’re sorting it out now. You have to do this to save the sport. You can’t have these guys fighting on this stuff.”

The one-year suspension handed down to Nick Diaz by the Nevada State Athletic Commission yesterday was a complete and total farce, and everyone with half a brain knows it.

Yes, weed is illegal inside of competition in Nevada, even if you have a medical marijuana license in another state. And yes, Diaz should have stopped smoking a little bit sooner than the eight days he says he did, if only to ensure that his donated urine sample on fight night was clean as a whistle.

I’m not a pothead. I’ve smoked the stuff before, and I didn’t like it. I doubt I’ll ever try it again. But the fact that Diaz—who had trace amounts of marijuana metabolites, and not THC evident of actual marijuana use on that day—got a full-year suspension while Overeem got nine months after admittedly taking anabolic steroids (and also ducking urine tests) is completely and undeniably absurd and asinine. 

Not only did Overeem receive a lighter sentence—he was actually praised by the chairman of the commission, Skip Avansino, after presenting a case that even made Overeem’s most ardent supporters cringe.

Overeem blamed everyone under the sun. He used a whack doctor with a history of malpractice and shady dealings in performance-enhancing drugs to support his already-flimsy case. And this only came about after Overeem somehow delayed the NSAC’s initial drug test request back in November for nearly a month, then tried to avoid Nevada commissioners for his second drug test in April.

And after all of this, the Nevada commission thanked Overeem, gave him a reduced sentence and begged him to consider fighting in their state at the end of the year. 

Nick Diaz, on the other hand, presented a well-reasoned case with actual law and real doctors to back it up, and he got the full-year suspension.

I can’t figure it out. The Nevada commission is often pointed to as one of the best in the world, but I’m beginning to think they might just be one of the worst.

You can go into a hearing and tell them the most outlandish stories you can think of, and you might get a reduced sentence. But challenge them in court and present them with facts, and you’ll probably find yourself sitting on the sidelines far longer.

Read more MMA news on BleacherReport.com

Free UFC Star Nick Diaz: The Ridiculous Suspension That Will Cost Him Dearly

If you’ve read much of my work at all over the past few years, you should know one thing. To me, Nick Diaz is a bona fide American hero, a working class icon and one of the most exciting fighters in UFC history. Nick Diaz is a great man. A man who is b…

If you’ve read much of my work at all over the past few years, you should know one thing. To me, Nick Diaz is a bona fide American hero, a working class icon and one of the most exciting fighters in UFC history. Nick Diaz is a great man. A man who is bad at keeping appointments, or his temper, but a great man nevertheless.

But that doesn’t affect what I’m about to say. I’d make this same case for Jake Ellenberger, Tim Sylvia or some other useless bag of wind who doesn’t provide me a single lick of entertainment.

Nick Diaz got screwed yesterday by the Nevada Athletic Commission, suspended for a year for the ridiculous crime of smoking marijuana.

In a hearing that seemed to last hours (just checked, it actually did last hours; glad it wasn’t just me), the commission managed to psychoanalyze Diaz, get him to reminisce about his first weed experience and admit that he didn’t stop smoking weed after he was last busted for it in Las Vegas.

That time, if you recall, was immediately after his amazing fight with Takanori Gomi. This time, he tested positive after a thrilling five-round decision loss to Carlos Condit. If that’s what weed does to a fighter, not only should it be legal, it should be mandatory. Recycled through the Vegas casinos to make our Saturday fight nights just a little more exciting.

I digress.

While the State of Nevada inadvertently conducted a pretty great interview with Diaz, what it failed to do, absolutely, was establish why or how marijuana was either a danger or a competitive edge. Heck, they couldn’t even establish that he was using the substance on the night of the fight or even any time that week. Two questions popped through my head over and over again: “Who cares?” and “What is the point of all this?”

Look, we all know that the prescription drug companies and booze distilleries are in a desperate battle to keep marijuana illegal in these United States. We know that the citizens of California saw through this obvious self interest and fraud, rejecting the criminalization of this valuable drug in the starkest terms. And we know, even Diaz haters know deep down, that smoking weed isn’t something that matters one way or another come fight night.

When Nick Diaz smokes marijuana, he does so legally. It offers him no advantages. It doesn’t affect either combatants health or welfare. So what is the state’s interest in meddling here? Why is Nevada testing fighters for marijuana? Who benefits from this sham, besides the state which gets to reach into Diaz’s pocket and rip free 30 percent of the purse he put his body on the line to earn?

These are the questions I’d be asking right now if I was a Nevada tax payer. I’m all for protecting fighters’ safety and keeping the playing field relatively level. I understand and embrace the Athletic Commission and its important role in making sure athletes survive these contests relatively unscathed. But persecuting pot smokers is not within this mission. It’s a farce.

Free Nick Diaz. It’s the right thing to do.

Read more MMA news on BleacherReport.com

UFC 146: The UFC’s Heavyweight Division Gets a Coming-out Party

UFC 146 is unlike anything else in the long history of the UFC. Never before has the promotion considered filling a card with heavyweight fights.The major reason it’s never happened is due to the lack of quality heavyweights in the UFC’s biggest weight…

UFC 146 is unlike anything else in the long history of the UFC. Never before has the promotion considered filling a card with heavyweight fights.

The major reason it’s never happened is due to the lack of quality heavyweights in the UFC’s biggest weight class in the past. Just a few years ago, the division had a few top contenders and a rash of guys who were as far away from title shots as you can possibly get. It’s hard to fill up a pay-per-view card when you have Tim Sylvia, Andrei Arlovski and not much else to speak of.

That’s no longer the case. The UFC’s heavyweight division has grown by leaps and bounds, and it’s now deep enough that a card of this nature could finally be created. The top of the division is more stacked than ever, with guys like Cain Velasquez, Frank Mir, Fabricio Werdum and the suspended Alistair Overeem all close to title contention. Rising young stars such as Travis Browne and Stefan Struve are filling out the middle of the division.

And that’s not even counting Daniel Cormier and Josh Barnett, who will make their way to the UFC after each fighting once more in Strikeforce.

Point being, the UFC’s heavyweights are ready for a showcase like the one they’ll get on Saturday night. Whether or not they’ll deliver exciting fights is a different story.

Read more MMA news on BleacherReport.com

UFC 148: Dana White Made Urijah Faber Believe He Was Fighting Ivan Menjivar

Urijah Faber’s new opponent at UFC 148 is a tough one. In some ways, Renan Barao may be a tougher opponent for Faber than even Dominick Cruz. The Brazilian has put together an incredible winning streak and has a devastating all-around game that could r…

Urijah Faber‘s new opponent at UFC 148 is a tough one. In some ways, Renan Barao may be a tougher opponent for Faber than even Dominick Cruz. The Brazilian has put together an incredible winning streak and has a devastating all-around game that could really give Faber problems when they meet for the interim bantamweight title on July 7 in Las Vegas.

Faber never thought he would be facing Barao, though. According to an interview with Pro MMA Radio, Faber was under the impression that Ivan Menjivar, and not Barao, would be the replacement for Cruz. Faber noted that Dana White told him that Michael McDonald was injured and that Barao didn’t want to leave Brazil, leaving him with the idea that he’d be facing Menjivar.

But that was all a ruse by White to keep the secret from getting out:

For like two days I thought I might be fighting Menjivar. Then the day of the announcement, I was like ‘Are you sure it’s not Barao?’ And he was like, ‘Yeah.’ But I had a feeling that it was. Then Dana apologized right before he announced it, for basically lying, which is kinda weird, I thought, because Barao was there. I don’t care who I fight, I told Dana I wouldn’t say anything anyway, if he was thinking I might spoil the surprise, or what the deal was.

This is par for the course. The UFC works hard to make fight announcements themselves, using a combination of their website and Twitter account.

A year ago, we saw most fights broken by a handful of major MMA websites. But the UFC decided to change the game by making their own fight announcements, often before they even have written bout agreements in hand from the fighters in question. Releasing news of fight bookings shortly after they receive verbal agreements from the fighters gives them a speed edge that can’t be replicated by journalists outside of the company.

I understand White’s need for secrecy in this situation. One of the drawing points for last Friday’s episode of The Ultimate Fighter was the announcement of Faber’s new opponent, so they took every precaution to keep that from happening.

In the end, we’re still getting the best fight possible. Barao is a legitimate stern test for Faber, and although I think “The California Kid” will ultimately come out on top, he’s facing a guy who he will not, and should not, take lightly.

Read more MMA news on BleacherReport.com